Telling a story is harder than it sounds. That has to do, in part, with the fact that writing is made up of many different tasks. You need to think about a plot, divide it into scenes, choose a point of view, develop characters… and, as if that was not enough, you also need to write. And go over your text. And go over it one more time.
Creating characters is probably the most neglected of these tasks. The world is full of manuals for constructing plots and arguments, from The Hero’s Journey, by Joseph Campbell, to Story, by Robert McKee. Those books have very useful tips for creating stories, but they don’t usually teach us how to build an original character. That’s why, in this article, we’re going to discuss seven tips to create a good character.
1. There Are No Secondary Characters
The origin of this phrase is debated. Some attribute it to Kurt Vonnegut, others to John Berger, and there will surely be someone who says it’s from Jorge Luis Borges. Fortunately, we are not preoccupied with philological discussions here.
Of course, we all know that stories have some characters that are more important than others. In Hamlet, Hamlet and Polonius don’t have the same prominence, that is clear. But what makes Polonius a great secondary character is precisely that he doesn’t know it. He acts as if he was the center of the story, because, after all, he has no reason to suspect that the play bears someone else’s name. Do you get the idea?
A good secondary character is built with the same care as a main character: they have motivations, problems, loves and fears. And that is precisely what makes them work well in the text.
2. Research, Research, Research
In the book Creating Unforgettable Characters, Linda Seger begins by talking, precisely, about the importance of research. Knowing is easier than inventing, and it’s also more appealing.
In Moby Dick, part of what makes Captain Ahab so magnetic is that Herman Melville was thoroughly familiar with the whaling trade. It was to be expected: during his youth, he spent almost five years at sea.
But not all research has to be so literal. Research is also reading a book about the French Revolution if the story is set in that period, or watching a documentary about a famous criminal if the character is a jewelry thief.
3. Beware of Caricatures
Some people call them “caricatures”; others, “stereotypes”; and there’s always people who take the opportunity to quote Jung and say “archetypes”. Truth is, we are all talking about the same thing: characters that can be described in a few words and that feel typical and repeated. For example, the evil villain who dresses in black and lives isolated from society, the good-natured sidekick who’s only good at making jokes, the antisocial but kind-hearted nerd, etc.
The main problem with these characters is that they are not interesting. A greedy banker is less interesting than a communist banker, and that’s why we get caught in El salto de papa, by Martín Sivak. A dumb model is something we’ve seen hundreds of times, and therefore more boring than an educated model; that’s what Alberto Fuguet explored in his book Por favor, rebobinar.
Storytelling involves dealing with the particular rather than the general. What follows the norm, what’s predictable and generic, is of no interest to us. This goes for both the stories and the characters. Not every character needs to be incredibly exceptional, but anyone who has talked more than half an hour with a person knows that everyone has some detail that makes them unique.
4. Everyone Needs a Little Conflict
Sometimes the best way to know what a character is like is to know what they want. Not only that: it’s also important to know why don’t they have what they want, and—the most important thing of all—what are they willing to do to get it.
That’s the engine of change, the force that moves the story. Frodo wants to destroy the ring, and half the world stands between him and Mordor. That conflict, necessarily, is going to tell us a lot about him as a person… well, as a hobbit.
5. Sahed of Gray Are Key
Hannibal Lecter, from The Silence of the Lambs, is one of the most memorable villains of recent decades. He is a murderer, a psychopath and a cannibal. But it’s not his crimes what make him unforgettable; there are many killers. Hannibal Lecter is interesting because, despite his wickedness, he’s intelligent, polite and extremely kind. The contrast between his behaviour and the horrors of which he is capable makes him a particularly fascinating monster.
And the other way around: if villains need virtues, heroes need flaws. No one can identify with perfection—or at least no one with a reasonable degree of sanity. That’s why over the past few years, Batman has been so much more popular than Superman. A good, honest, invincible man, without nuances, feels too flat. We need contrast to feel like the character is alive; richness lies in contradictions.
As Walt Whitman put it:
Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)
6. A Good Conversation
There are few things more characteristic than the way we speak. We all have a friend, an aunt, or a co-worker who says weird words, uses unfamiliar sayings, or cracks unexpected jokes. Ignatius J. Reilly, from A Confederacy of Dunces, is as well-remembered for his conservative opinions as for his use of idioms and archaisms in speech. Not all characters need to be as outlandish as Reilly; it’s enough for them to be true to themselves.
Many authors say that, before writing about a character, “they take them for a coffee”. It’s not literal, of course (or so we want to believe). What they mean is that, before putting their characters in the situations of the plot, they imagine a casual chat in which they ask questions and observe their reactions.
It’s like a first date: a way to get to know each other. And it’s also a great opportunity to identify those speech and behavior peculiarities that make a character look alive.
7. Don’t Get Stuck in the Past
Our past experiences condition—at least to some extent—our future decisions. But that doesn’t mean they determine them. We are a product of our past, but we are not its victims; or at least not in a linear and predictable way.
Psychosocial struggles—blame, trauma, grief—can drive part of the plot, but they don’t have to determine every decision of the characters. And this is not just to give desire a more prominent role. The problem with permanently going back to the past is almost grammatical. The story becomes parenthetical: the characters end up separated from the action by long fragments of text in the past perfect that explain past events which are not always interesting.
This does not mean that characters can’t have a backstory. In fact, that life journey is very convenient. But you have to know when to bring that background into the light and when to keep it in the shadows.
Conclusion: How to Create a Unique Character
There are a thousand techniques for creating a character, and none is foolproof. In writing, there are no recipes, which is both a curse—because it makes everything more uncertain—and a blessing—because it makes everything more varied. Actually, the best counselor is practice; the second best, intuition.
Seven tricks for writing a character aren’t a lot, but they are a great starting point. You have to start somewhere. It’s also not possible to apply them all at once; it’s a good idea to know how to switch between different techniques, what to use and what not to use depending on each circumstance. Maybe your story needs caricatures. Maybe your character needs to constantly talk about their past. It all depends. Actually, the best possible advice—this goes as a bonus—is to start writing. Good luck with that!
